Logo Carenity
Logo Carenity
Join now! Log in
flag en
flag fr flag es flag de flag it flag us
Home Forum Conditions Magazine Medications Surveys
Join now! Log in
  • Forum
  • Conditions
  • Magazine
  • Medications
  • Surveys
  • Home
  • Forums
  • General forums
  • News from the media
  • Fats or carbs: What causes obesity?
 Back
News from the media

Fats or carbs: What causes obesity?

  •  46 views
  •  0 support
  •  1 comment

avatar Margarita_k

Margarita_k

Community manager
20/07/2018 at 12:47

Good advisor

avatar Margarita_k

Margarita_k

Community manager

Last activity on 07/10/2020 at 11:39

Joined in 2016


1,195 comments posted | 154 in the News from the media group

2 of their responses were helpful to members


Rewards

  • Good Advisor

  • Contributor

  • Messenger

  • Committed

  • Explorer

  • Evaluator


 View profileView  Add a friendAdd  Write

Too many carbohydrates or too much fat? Opinions as to which parts of our diets are likely to cause obesity are split. A recent study takes a closer look at the effects of diet on weight and health.

Earlier this year, Medical News Today reported on a study that pitted the potential benefits of the low-carb diet against those of the low-fat one.

The scientists asked which type of diet would be best for shedding excess weight.

Their conclusion? In essence, that it is hard to tell.

Both have pros and cons; some people may benefit more from laying off the fats, whereas others may see better results by sticking to a low-carb dietary plan.

Both carbs (which are a primary source of glucose, or simple sugar) and fats have been blamed for increasing a person's likelihood of facing obesity, and studies keep debating these points, so the argument is far from settled.

Recently, the view that an excessive carb intake may be the main dietary cause of obesity has had more traction, though some researchers have questioned this.

In a paper now published in the journal Cell Metabolism, researchers from two institutions — the Institute of Genetics and Developmental Biology at the Chinese Academy of Sciences in Beijing and the University of Aberdeen in the United Kingdom — have once more turned the cards, suggesting that we should look once more to fatty foods.

Sugar intake had no impact on weight

In what they think is the largest study of its kind to date, lead researcher Prof. John Speakman and team worked with mice to test the effects of three macronutrients – carbohydrates, fats, and protein — on body fat accumulation.

The scientists turned to the murine model because, as they explain, asking human participants to follow one type of diet and evaluating them for very long periods of time is extremely tricky.

But looking at rodents — which have similar metabolic mechanisms — could offer crucial clues and workable evidence.

Mice belonging to five different genetically engineered strains were assigned to one of 30 various types of diet, including variations on their content of fat, carbs, and protein.

The mice were kept on their respective diets for a period of 3 months — which counts as 9 years would for humans.

Throughout this time, they were assessed for changes in body weight and body fat content, to see which of the mice would end up becoming overweight.

The scientists found that only an excessive intake of fats increased adiposity (body fat content) in mice, while carbohydrates — including up to 30 percent of calories derived from sucrose — had no impact.

Moreover, a combined fatty and sugary diet did not increase body fat more than a fatty diet did on its own.

As for protein intake, the research team says that there was no evidence that it affected the intake of other macronutrients or the amount of body fat.

And why does the intake of fat lead to obesity? The researchers believe that fats "appeal" to the brain's reward system, stimulating a craving for an excessive amount of calories, which then determines weight gain.

"A clear limitation of this study," as Prof. Speakman explains, "is that it is based on mice rather than humans."

"However, mice have lots of similarities to humans in their physiology and metabolism, and we are never going to do studies where the diets of humans are controlled in the same way for such long periods."

 


Medical News Today
Follow

Other groups...

News from the media
All things Christmas
Carenity News
Feedback for Carenity
Fun and games
Good to know
How to use Carenity
Let's talk about COVID-19
Life beyond illness
Procedures and Paperwork
Youth patients with chronic conditions

Give your opinion

Survey

What do you think about the Carenity Forum and community?

All comments

avatar exit

Unregistered member

06/12/2018 at 08:31

History shows that since man stopped being a hunter-gather, eating only animal, bird and fish, including its fats with very little carbs from greens, and started eating carbs like sugar and wheat etc, he has become fat, in many cases obese with other Western medical conditions such as diabetes, high blood pressure and cholesterol etc. The Native Indian Pima tribe of America are a prime example of this, they were hunter-gathers, fit, lean and healthy, then during the late 18th and early 19th century their streams was diverted, animals culled almost to extinction and they could barely survive, so they went to the American government for help, and they gave them wheat and sugar based products. Now what's left of the pima tribe all have diabetes and are obese. This has been seen in many cultures including the Inuit's; any culture that has been moved away from it's original diet of meat, fish and poultry, including its fats and small amounts of carbs from greens, now shows signs of the Western ailments of diabetes, obesity etc.


Fats or carbs: What causes obesity? https://www.carenity.co.uk/forum/other-discussions/news-from-the-media/fats-or-carbs-what-causes-obesity-2488 2018-12-06 08:31:41

Give your opinion

Survey

What do you think about the Carenity Forum and community?

Articles to discover...

The identity shift: How to build a life that includes, but isn’t defined by, illness

05/05/2025 | Advice

The identity shift: How to build a life that includes, but isn’t defined by, illness

Medications and driving: Are your prescriptions putting you at risk behind the wheel?

26/04/2025 | Advice

Medications and driving: Are your prescriptions putting you at risk behind the wheel?

Can journaling bring real benefits for chronic illness symptoms?

25/04/2025 | Advice

Can journaling bring real benefits for chronic illness symptoms?

Aspartame and its effects on our health

19/04/2025 | Nutrition

Aspartame and its effects on our health

NHS - Get help with prescription costs

12/11/2019 | Procedures & paperwork

NHS - Get help with prescription costs

Diclofenac to become a prescription drug

21/01/2015 | News

Diclofenac to become a prescription drug

Opioids Causing Concerns, Problems for Chronic Pain Patients

14/10/2016 | News

Opioids Causing Concerns, Problems for Chronic Pain Patients

Do you have the winter blues?

21/10/2014 | News

Do you have the winter blues?

icon cross

Does this topic interest you?

Join the 500 000 patients registered on our platform, get information on your condition or on that of your family member, and discuss it with the community

Join now! Join now! Join now! Join now! Join now!

It’s free and confidential

Subscribe

You wish to be notified of new comments

 

Your subscription has been taken into account

Join now! Log in

About

  • Who are we?
  • The Carenity team
  • The Science and Ethics Committee
  • Contributors
  • Carenity in the news
  • Certifications and awards
  • Data For Good
  • Our scientific publications
  • Discover our studies
  • Editorial policy
  • Code of conduct
  • Our commitments
  • Legal notice
  • Terms of use
  • Cookies management
  • Contact
  • Carenity for professionals

Quick access

  • Health magazine
  • Search a forum
  • Learn about a condition
  • See medication reviews
  • List of forums (A-Z)
  • List of condition info sheets (A-Z)
  • List of medication fact sheets (A-Z)
  • Language flag fr flag de flag es flag it flag us

The www.carenity.co.uk website does not constitute or replace professional medical advice.